Call us now

Call us free and speak with a member of our client relationship team who will be happy to help.

0808 271 4668

Lines are open from 9am to 7pm Monday to Friday and 10am to 5pm on a Saturday.

or

Arrange callback

Let us know a suitable time for us to call you back.

 
or

Thank You

Thank you for contacting Shoosmiths Serious Injury. Your enquiry is important to us. A dedicated member from our client relationship team will be in touch with you shortly.

Message us

If you would prefer to write to us, you can send us a message by clicking below and we will get back to you Send us a message

Report: Over 90 patients harmed by Mr Mian Munawar Shah's surgical incompetence

11 March 2025

A new report from Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust has disclosed that of 382 former patients of Mr Mian Munawar Shah whose care was reviewed, more than 90 suffered moderate or severe harm due to his surgical incompetence.

Shoosmiths Serious Injury, who are representing many of the affected former patients in medical negligence claims, have also found that in some cases where patients received recall outcome letters indicating no harm, subsequent independent expert evidence has revealed there was significant harm caused by Mr Shah's care.

Many of the patients identified in the report were treated as long ago as 2010. Although, it is more than three years since their treatment they may still be in time to investigate a potential claim, and we urge anyone in this situation to take legal advice.

Medical negligence specialist Nick Tubb, Partner, comments: “The Trust’s report refers to a complaint to the GMC in 2019 as being one of the key events leading to the eventual suspension of Mr Shah in 2021. When I acted for Joanne Aldridge in 2016 in her successful claim against Mr Shah relating to surgery in 2010, we made a complaint to the GMC. This was three years earlier than the complaint referenced in the report, but our complaint was rejected. This was a missed opportunity to act earlier which could have prevented injuries to more patients.”

Becca Horley, Associate, comments: “The report reveals alarming issues with orthopaedic surgery at Walsall Manor Hospital. Our clients' lives have been devastated by poor treatment outcomes, leaving many unable to work and dependent on daily care and assistance from loved ones.”

Watch Joanne Aldridge describing her experience of the negligent surgery performed by Mr Shah:

Share

Disclaimer

This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before acting on any of the information given. © Shoosmiths LLP 2025

Contact our experts

Morning

Who we work with

  • Brain Injury Group
  • CESS
  • ABIF

Our accreditations

  • Accredited Personal Injury
  • Apil
  • Avma