Delivering legal expertise since 1845

Perineal tearing claims

Experiencing a tear during childbirth can be a traumatic event, both physically and emotionally. While minor tears are quite common and, if dealt with appropriately, will not take too long to heal, some vaginal tears can be severe and may have been caused by negligence surrounding the birth.

How are perineal tears classified and treated?

A perineal tear is an injury that occurs in the area between the vagina and the anus, known as the perineum, typically during childbirth. These tears can vary in severity and are classified as follows:

Tears are quite common during vaginal childbirth and can cause discomfort and complications if not properly managed.

Who can make a perineal tearing compensation claim?

A claim for a tear during childbirth can be made by the mother who experienced the tear if the tear was caused or worsened by medical negligence.

Childbirth tears, especially severe ones like third- or fourth-degree tears, can have long-term physical and psychological effects. If the tear was preventable or if the healthcare providers failed to provide the appropriate care, the mother may have grounds for a medical negligence claim. The mother may also be able to make a claim if, once a tear was present, there was a failure by the healthcare provider to provide appropriate treatment for the tear.

 

Birth injury services

Birth injury claims    Cerebral palsy claims    Stillbirth claims    twin birth injury claims    Wrongful birth claims    Maternity negligence claims

 

What medical negligence can lead to problems with tears? 

Medical negligence related to perineal tears can occur in several ways, potentially leading to serious health issues for the mother. Here are some common examples:

Why choose Shoosmiths for your claim

Choosing Shoosmiths Serious Injury team for your tearing claim offers several advantages:

  • Specialist expertise: Ranked top tier in leading legal directories, and listed among The Times Best Law Firms for Clinical Negligence in 2024, we have a dedicated team of medical negligence solicitors with extensive experience in handling complex birth injury claims, including those involving perineal tears.
  • Proven track record: Our firm has a strong track record of successfully securing compensation for clients in medical negligence cases, demonstrating our ability to handle challenging claims effectively.
  • Comprehensive support: We provide compassionate and comprehensive support throughout the claims process, ensuring that you feel supported and informed at every step. We are sensitive to your needs but will fight your corner and push the boundaries in your case, when the need arises.
  • National reach: With a national presence, we can offer our services across the country, making it convenient for you to access our expertise.
  • Client-centric approach: We are known for putting our clients first; prioritising your needs and wellbeing while pursuing claims with determination and professionalism. 
  • ‘No win, no fee’: We take suitable cases on a ‘no win, no fee’ basis with no upfront payment required so there is no financial risk to you.

We come to you

We understand this may be a difficult and challenging time for you and your family. We can talk you through the process at your own pace. We listen. Indeed, our first visit may just involve a chat and a cup of tea.

Medical negligence experts

Ranked top tier in leading legal directories and awarded Law Firm of the Year 2022, we have over 165 years of experience in advising people and businesses.

People first, lawyers second

Shoosmiths' experts are on your side – our lawyers are caring, fearless and treasure the values of openness and honesty.

About Shoosmiths

Perineal tearing client stories

Compensation for woman who suffered an untreated tear during childbirth

 

View client stories

Our birth injury experts

Meet our experts

Sarah Harper

Sarah Harper

Legal Director (FCILEx)

Sarah Harper

Sarah Harper is a Legal Director in the National Medical Negligence Team. She is an accredited member of the Law Society of England and Wales for Clinical Negligence.

Susan Prior

Susan Prior

Partner

Susan Prior

Sue is a Clinical Negligence Partner and leads a team in the Clinical Negligence department in the Thames Valley Office.

Alice Folliss

Alice Folliss

Associate

Alice Folliss

Alice qualified in December 2022 and is an Associate in the Clinical Negligence Department.

What our clients say

Making a tearing claim with Shoosmiths

If you suspect medical negligence is the cause of your injury, please seek advice from one of our medical negligence solicitors to explore the potential for a claim and to obtain advice on your options for seeking compensation and ensuring accountability.

  1. Contact us call or message the team
  2. Grounds for claim – we will assess and discuss whether your claim is likely to succeed
  3. We come to you – we will visit you at home or in the hospital to talk you through the process
  4. Funding your claim – we can offer various funding options, including ‘no win, no fee’ and legal aid, depending on the circumstances of your claim.
  5. Gathering evidence – we will obtain medical records, witness statements and expert evidence to support your claim and to calculate what compensation you might be entitled to.

Tearing claim FAQs

  • What are the risk factors for perineal tearing?

    Several factors can increase the risk of experiencing a tear during childbirth, including:

    • First vaginal birth: Women having their first vaginal delivery are at a higher risk because it is the first time the perineum is experiencing this stretching.
    • Large baby: Babies weighing more than 4 kg (approximately 9 lbs) can put more pressure on the perineum and so increase the likelihood of tearing.
    • Prolonged second stage of labour: A longer pushing phase, while the baby is in the birth canal, can contribute to the risk.
    • Rapid delivery: Where the baby descends very quickly through the birth canal, which means that the perineum does not have time to stretch gradually.
    • Instrumental delivery: The use of forceps or ventouse assistance during delivery can increase the chances of a tear.
    • Shoulder dystocia: This occurs when the baby’s shoulder gets stuck behind the mother’s pubic bone during delivery. Specific skill in manoeuvring the baby safely out of the birth canal is required.
    • Older maternal age: Older mothers may have a higher risk due to reduced elasticity.
    • Episiotomy: An incision made in the perineum to assist delivery can sometimes lead to more severe tears. Episiotomy used to be very common during childbirth, but this technique is no longer routinely used.
  • What complications can arise from a perineal tear?

    Complications from perineal tears can vary depending on the severity of the tear and how it is treated or managed:

    • Pain: Persistent pain in the perineal area, especially during activities like sitting or walking.
    • Infection: The wound can become infected, leading to redness, swelling, and discharge.
    • Bleeding: Significant bleeding can occur, particularly with more severe tears.
    • Bladder issues: Damage to the pelvic floor muscles can lead to urinary incontinence, which can be temporary or long-term.
    • Bowel issues: Difficulty controlling bowel movements, especially with third- and fourth-degree tears, potentially causing fecal (bowel) incontinence.
    • Sexual dysfunction: Pain during sexual intercourse and reduced sexual function and sensation.
    • Delayed healing: The tear may reopen or take longer to heal, requiring additional medical intervention.
    • Emotional impact: Feelings of trauma, depression, and impaired bonding with the baby due to pain and recovery time. The trauma of a tear and impact on sexual function can also affect the relationship with a partner.
  • How do I know if I have a medical negligence claim for a perineal tear?

    Contact us and one of our experienced solicitors will assess your case to determine whether you have a valid medical negligence claim. We will need to establish a few key elements:

    Duty of care: You must show that the healthcare provider owed you a duty of care. This is generally straightforward in a medical setting, as healthcare professionals are expected to provide a standard level of care.

    Breach of duty: You need to prove that the healthcare provider breached this duty by failing to meet the standard of care that a reasonably competent healthcare provider would provide under similar circumstances.  In the context of tears, this could include:

    • Failure to recognise risk factors: If healthcare providers do not identify and manage known risk factors for perineal tears, such as a large baby or prolonged labour, the risk of severe tearing can increase.
    • Improper use of instruments: Incorrect use of forceps or ventouse during delivery can cause or worsen perineal tears.
    • Inadequate episiotomy: An episiotomy (a surgical cut made at the opening of the vagina during childbirth) that is performed incorrectly or unnecessarily can lead to more severe tearing.
    • Delayed or inadequate repair: If a tear is not promptly and properly repaired, it can lead to complications and worsen the injury.
    • Lack of proper supervision: Inexperienced or unsupervised medical staff may not handle the delivery process correctly, increasing the risk of tears.

    Causation: You must demonstrate that the breach of duty directly caused harm to you or your baby. This means showing a clear link between the healthcare provider’s actions (or inactions) and the injury or illness suffered.

    Damages: Finally, you need to show that you suffered damage as a result of the negligence. This may include physical injury, emotional distress, additional medical expenses, and other related costs.

    You do not need to address these issues on your own. If you believe these factors may apply to your situation, please contact us. We would be pleased to comprehensively assess your case and assist you in understanding your legal options, including whether you may have a valid claim.

  • What evidence do I need to support my claim?

    To support a claim for a tear due to medical negligence, we will help you gather several key pieces of evidence:

    • Medical records: We will obtain all relevant medical records, including prenatal care, labour, and delivery notes. These records will enable us to consider whether there were any failures in the care provided.
    • Witness statements: Statements from anyone who witnessed the care received, such as you and your family.
    • Expert evidence: Independent medico-legal experts provide opinions on whether the standard of care was breached and how this breach caused harm (causation). Their testimony is crucial in establishing negligence. They are also needed to support the losses claimed.
    • Complaints correspondence: Any communication with healthcare providers, including emails, letters, and a complaints response.
    • Photographs and videos: Visual evidence and any visible symptoms can be useful in illustrating the harm caused.
    • Financial records: Documentation of any financial losses incurred due to the negligence, such as medical bills, travel expenses, and lost income, can support your claim for compensation.
  • How do I claim compensation for tearing?

    Contact us for a free initial consultation. One of our expert medical negligence solicitors will assess the details you give us and advise you whether they think your claim has reasonable prospects. They will help you to understand your options and explain the legal process and what you can expect. They will also talk to you about funding the case.

    We understand that if you are worried that something has gone wrong during the birth of your child, you may be in pain and you may be upset and confused. To put you at ease, a member of our experienced team will talk to you about your concerns and can advise on the steps to be taken. They will also discuss with you how your claim can be funded, including whether the option of legal aid is available to you.

    To begin a claim:

    Call us on 03700 868687

    OR

    Message us using our enquiry form and we will get in touch.

    If you have a case, we will be with you throughout the legal process, visiting you in person to help you find out what has happened and to claim compensation for you and your family if there has been negligence.

  • How much compensation can I expect for a perineal tear claim?

    The amount of compensation you can expect for a perineal tear claim depends on several factors, including the severity of the injury and the impact on your life. Here are some general guidelines:

    Type of damages

    • General damages: These cover pain, suffering, and loss of amenity (how your injuries have affected your lifestyle or way of life).
    • Special damages: These cover financial losses and expenses incurred due to the injury and may include medical costs, ongoing care, travel expenses, treatment costs and loss of earnings. Anticipated future costs can also be claimed.

    Speaking with one of our specialist injury solicitors will enable us to give a more accurate estimate based on your individual situation.

  • How long do I have to make a claim after experiencing a perineal tear?
    In general, you have three years from the date of the injury or from the date you became aware of the injury to make a compensation claim for a perineal tear. This time limit ensures that claims are made while evidence is still fresh and relevant. 

    However, the rules on limitation are complex and so it is important to consult with a specialist solicitor as soon as possible to ensure you don’t miss any critical deadlines. We can provide detailed advice based on your specific situation and ensure that a claim is investigated in good time. 
  • Can I make a claim on a ‘no win, no fee’ basis?

    Yes, you can make a perineal tear medical negligence claim on a ‘no win, no fee’ basis. This arrangement, also known as a Conditional Fee Agreement (CFA), means that you do not have the financial risk of paying legal fees upfront. If your claim is successful your opponent pays most of your legal costs and only any unrecovered costs will come from a percentage of your settlement, that we agree with you in advance.  An insurance policy will protect you if your claim is unsuccessful.

    There are other forms of funding available in some cases and we will discuss the details of these with you when we take on your case.

  • Can I get legal aid funding for a perineal tearing claim?

    Legal aid can help cover the costs of pursuing a birth injury compensation claim in circumstances where your baby has suffered a brain injury either during pregnancy, at birth or during the first 8 weeks of life. When we speak to you, we will be able to assess whether your claim will be eligible for legal aid. If you are not eligible then we can advise you about other methods of funding, including ‘no win, no fee’ agreements and insurance policy funding. 

    Talk to one of our medical negligence lawyers to find out if you qualify for legal aid. 

  • How long does it take to settle a perineal tear compensation claim?

    The time it takes to settle a perineal tear compensation claim can vary widely depending on:

    • Complexity of the case: More complex cases, especially those involving severe injuries can take longer to resolve.
    • Evidence gathering: The time needed to collect medical records, expert opinions, and other evidence can impact the duration of the claim.
    • Defendant’s response: If the healthcare provider admits liability, the process can be quicker. However, if they contest the claim, it may take longer and could potentially go to court.
    • Negotiation and settlement: Most claims are settled out of court through negotiations, which can speed up the process.
    • Court proceedings: If it is necessary to start court proceedings, it can take several years to reach a conclusion. However, there are still opportunities to settle the claim throughout that process.

    Once a settlement is agreed, you can expect to receive your compensation within a few weeks.

    Each case is unique; speak to one of our specialist solicitors who can provide a more accurate timeline based on the specifics of your situation.

Helpful guides

 

Funding cerebral palsy claims

What is the Early Notification Scheme for maternity negligence claims?

How to change your solicitor to us

Medical negligence guides

Contact our experts

Sorry, there are a few problems with the information you have entered. Please correct these before continuing.

Submitting

One moment please...

Thank You

Your submission has been received. We'll be in touch soon.

Who we work with

  • Brain Injury Group
  • CESS
  • ABIF
  • Headway
  • SIA
  • Back Up
  • BABICM
  • Bens Heroes Trust

Our accreditations

  • Accredited Personal Injury
  • Apil
  • Avma
  • Clinical Negligence
  • Legal 500
  • UK Chambers
  • The Society Of Clinical Injury Lawyers